Michael Fernie profile picture Michael Fernie a year ago 52
Blog

Why Are Cold Starts So Loud?

We love a cold start at CT, but why do cars always sound so great after being left to cool down?

Remind me later
Why Are Cold Starts So Loud? - Blog

It’s early in the morning, with dew still clinging to the tips of your lawn as you stumble out the house to begin your day with the usual start-up of your own little piece of automotive sanctuary. And it seems that – the colder the conditions are – the meatier your car sounds as it rips through the morning silence with a cacophony of valve clicks and miniature combustion cycles.

The cold start is one of the greatest pleasures for any petrolhead to experience, but why does a car always sound especially fruity after it has been sitting dormant for a while, especially in cold conditions?

V10s sound especially violent during a cold start

To start with, a car’s ECU decides that the engine has to idle higher when the engine is cold to stop it from stalling. This is programmed into the ECU via a start-up map, which allows a richer air/fuel mixture to enter the cylinders. Ideally, efficient combustion occurs at a higher temperature than that of the ambient temperature of a cold engine, where the fuel can vaporise naturally and be burned.

When it is cold, more fuel is added to the air/fuel mixture to make up for the lack of natural vaporisation. So the AFR (air-fuel ratio) is seen by the ECU to be leaner than usual (below the Stoichiometric ratio of 14.7:1) so it compensates for this with extra fuel to make up for the unburned fuel due to the cold.

Why Are Cold Starts So Loud? - Blog

Since this increase in fuel could potentially lead to a clogging of the ignition system and therefore an engine stall, the ECU increases the engine speed at initial idle to make sure that all of the excess fuel is being forced out of the cylinders quicker than normal. Once a desired engine temperature is reached, the idle speed will slowly descend to its usual value. The ECU does this by returning the AFR back to the Stoichiometric mixture for the engine, just like the choke on cars featuring carburettors. Any excess fuel that makes it to the exhaust system is generally vaporised by secondary-heated air it’s mixed with in the manifold, with this combustion helping to heat the catalytic converter from cold and amping up the volume for a cold start.

Bosch, a company that knows a thing or two about engine management - summarises it all nicely:

“Gasoline is less likely to vaporize when it is cold. Even if it is adequately vaporized, some fuel condenses on the cold parts of the engine before it can be burned. The engine requires extra fuel for starting so that, in spite of vaporisation and condensation problems, the engine still receives a combustible air-fuel mixture”.

The components within an engine will also naturally shrink ever-so-slightly as it cools down, therefore tolerances decrease and the engine can become ‘tight’ as components contract. The lubricating oil will also have increased in viscosity as it cooled, thus meaning that the components will be slightly less lubricated than usual. Therefore the additional engine speed implemented by the ECU allows the engine to produce an increase in torque through to the crankshaft, rotating the engine’s components and aiding them against the slight increase in mechanical friction caused by the tightness.

As mentioned earlier, before fuel injection became the norm for internal combustion engines, a choke valve was needed to create a richer AFR at start-up. Having to be manually operated when turning the key, the valve would close over the air inlet to the carburettor, thus ‘choking’ the AFR and creating a rich mixture to keep the engine from stalling. You would then have to gauge when the engine was warm enough to slowly open the valve back up again, allowing full airflow back into the carburettors. Thankfully, fuel injection systems have fully replaced carbs, so now the ECU does all that hard work for you.

A carburetor cross-section, showing the choke in a fully open poisition
A carburetor cross-section, showing the choke in a fully open poisition

Although it might wake up your neighbours in the morning – especially when coupled with a lack of exhaust-silencing – a cold start-up function within the ECU is a necessity in this day and age, seeing as we have abandoned the choke as a mechanical device. The cold winter months might be freezing, wet and a bit depressing, but cold starts can surely put a smile on the face of any true petrolhead, whatever the weather. Heck, it even provides a decent soundtrack while you de-ice your windscreen, so who can complain!