The feed algorithm is changing. Here's what you need to know.

Hello CTZens,

Hello CTZens,

We make changes to the feed algorithm all the time in an effort to make the feed as relevant, fun and interesting as possible for each user. To continue this process, we have decided to make a fairly drastic change to the way posts are sorted and selected when viewing a “hot” feed. You can expect to see this change apply to your feed in the next day or so.

We want to make CT the best platform out there that achieves the following things:

  • Stay up-to-date with breaking news from the car world
  • Share, discover and discuss things with like-minded enthusiasts
  • Follow and see content from your favourite personalities, publishers and brands in one place

Until now we have used a very similar ranking system to that used by reddit (and reddit-inspired community sites). We based the rankings on the number of comments and the number of upvotes, with some additional factors like the content type, community, and how often you visit. Posts that get engagement more quickly than other posts “rise” to the top of the feed. They then begin to move back down the feed as they get older.

This worked well to surface popular content throughout the day but it has some limitations. Firstly, it doesn’t work well when combined with following users (as well as topics). If you follow a user, you don’t want to miss out on their posts, even if they aren’t very popular overall. Secondly, as you scroll down the feed, the posts decrease in “hotness” meaning that after page 2 or so, the posts can be quite mixed in quality. It also means that the best posts that are older can’t be found easily and in some cases disappear completely!

The feed algorithm is changing. Here's what you need to know.

“Awesome! How does it work?”

It’s actually pretty simple.

The feed will order all of the posts by publish date. Scroll down to go back in time. Scroll back to where you read up until last time.

Posts from users that you follow will always display on the feed, regardless of how many votes and comments they have.

Editorial articles, editor’s picks, and the occasional sponsored post will always appear on the feed. This is the same as the feed currently behaves.

Posts from your communities will require a certain “hotness” to reach your feed. Once they are deemed “hot” enough by the algorithm they will be inserted into your feed. The “hotness” is very similar to how the old feed works - it’s based on the number of upvotes, comments, and some “magic” that we put in.

There’s one major change to this calculation - communities. Posts from larger and/or more active communities will need more votes/comments to reach the hot feed. This will hopefully help the imbalances between the large and small communities, and it’ll make your main feed more diverse.

We will continuously tweak this balance. As communities grow, posts in those communities will start to need more popularity.

The feed algorithm is changing. Here's what you need to know.

“Okay, so that all applies to the “My Feed” hot sort order, what about the other feeds?”

All Posts: This is sorted by publish date as well, but it will only show posts of a certain “hotness”. It does not include the community weightings in this “hotness” calculation.

Hot feed for communities: Exactly the same as for all posts, but the required “hotness” changes depending on what community you are viewing.

“But I want to see the hottest posts of the day!”

Switch your sorting to “Top” and choose “Top today” or “Last 24 hours” (depends if you are viewing the website or in the app.

Comments

Tall_Dallas

No matter what I click on (Hot, Latest, Top) I get the same first 10 posts. So, what, I’m supposed to scroll down 5+ pages to see something new no matter which order I request them in? … You’re about to lose a ton of traffic guys. The beauty of “latest” is supposed to be a live feed of what people are posting so you can see activity from all the groups you’re subscribed to. IE: A shortcut from clicking on each group individually and seeing what each section is posting. Now it’s just a tiny bit different than the “hottest” feed. Which will prevent new posts from being upvoted and thus most new posts will just wither away into the ether as it’s too difficult for anyone to find and vote on new content. … I read your long post and realize what you’re trying to do. I think a side-banner with the top posts from various groups which would allow you to see other trending (new and being quickly liked) would have been a FAR better alternative to the explained adjustments made. Response?

01/27/2016 - 16:13 |
4 | 1

This is a bug. The team is looking into it now.

The new feeds have not been rolled-out yet.

01/27/2016 - 16:15 |
0 | 0

To respond to the question about missing the best posts of the day - this is what the “top” sort order can be used for. We’re confident that this change will make the “hot” feed more usable for most people. If it doesn’t work out we will change it again.

01/27/2016 - 16:50 |
0 | 0
Mr.PurpleV12

This sounds fantasitic.

01/27/2016 - 16:28 |
1 | 0
Gabz

Can’t wait to see how this goes!

01/27/2016 - 16:48 |
0 | 0
Scott Duncan

Just one quick question…… when are you going to buy a BMW?

01/27/2016 - 17:09 |
5 | 0

OP pls respond!

01/27/2016 - 17:39 |
13 | 0
Arno

“the occasional sponsored post will always appear on the feed”

I hope those posts are occasional because right now they aren’t. The whole feed is spammed full with Carscoops and other sponsors who just post links to their website, sometimes even links that have nothing to do with what they write in their post. I get that running CarThrottle requires money, but I don’t think this should compromise the quality of the content.

I want to see interesting posts made by other CTzen, not some crap about which people will appear in the Buick superbowl ad or another cry-video by Vehicle Virgins.

Also, can I add, please please pleeaaaase allow normal CTzen to post in the News community!!

01/27/2016 - 17:11 |
3 | 1
Adnan Ebrahim

In reply to by Arno

Hey Arno - accounts like Carscoops aren’t sponsors. They are publishers who want to post relevant car stories to our audience, in a similar way to how they’d use Facebook to distribute news stories to a certain audience. Sponsored posts are clearly marked, so you’ll know when you see one.

01/27/2016 - 17:39 |
3 | 0
Anonymous

In reply to by Arno

News community is now open. We will try and combat spam but it really ruins the community when it’s so full of irrelevant posts.

01/27/2016 - 17:53 |
0 | 0
DragzMR2

Just as I was getting sick of all the irrelevant-bullsh*t posts on the hottest page. Hope this changes things,we need CT!

01/27/2016 - 17:20 |
0 | 0
CSL Motorsport

Nice to see that you guys are making the best website in the world even better, suck on that youporn!

01/27/2016 - 17:42 |
8 | 1

<3

01/27/2016 - 22:37 |
1 | 0
Kyle H 1

Are there seriously people who don’t have the attention spans to read a brief article?

01/27/2016 - 18:10 |
0 | 0
Anonymous

George Wilson? All that comes to mind is the mechanic from the novel The Great Gatsby :)

01/27/2016 - 19:40 |
0 | 0
Anonymous

In reply to by Anonymous (not verified)

Haha yes! Also a guy in the Dennis the Menace movie???

01/27/2016 - 22:37 |
0 | 0
Alex P

Nice! Now, you guys need to work on fixing the app where my feed just ends after however many posts. I guess it could be good to keep me off CT for a little while (LOL), but I’d still like to see older posts I may have missed. This goes for my feed and any specific community I look at.

01/27/2016 - 21:51 |
0 | 0
Anonymous

In reply to by Alex P

Remy (Android dev) fixed this bug today! Expect it in the next App update

01/27/2016 - 22:37 |
1 | 0

Sponsored Posts