Obsolete Engines 101: The Mythical “V4″

The automobile as we know it (internal combustion, wheels, gears, etc.) has been around for a long time. 1672 is widely regarded as the beginning of the automobile, when Ferdinand Verbiest attached...
Share Share on Facebook

 

Share Share on Twitter Share Share ▼

The automobile as we know it (internal combustion, wheels, gears, etc.) has been around for a long time. 1672 is widely regarded as the beginning of the automobile, when Ferdinand Verbiest attached some wheels to a steam generator and created a vehicle that, by golly, moved itself.  Most people point to Karl Benz as the father of the modern automobile, so that would pretty much mean it came into life with the granting of a patent in 1886.  In the ensuing 123 years, a lot of ideas and concepts that were deemed state-of-the-art, then normal, have long since come and gone.  Some cars used to use leather as the friction surface on the clutch, because it was one of the grippiest, longest-lasting materials available at the time.

This means that the automobile has gone through a huge amount of evolution and reinvention as the years have gone by.  It’s a pretty big market, with the average now at about 1 car per 11 people on earth, so the incentive to have an up-to-date product is pretty strong.  Looking back at trends in the past show some interesting ideas that have sprouted and faded.  This is the first in a series of articles focusing on obsolete, outdated, or just plain unusual technology.  Inspiration for this article goes to Michael Torbert, who brought up the question “has anyone ever made a V4?”  Answer: Yes, they have.

The V4

When you talk to most car-ignorant people about cars, and ask them what kind of engine their Camry (or whatever) has, they’re liable to spout out something like “I think it’s got a V4?”  Most of them don’t know exactly how uncommon a V4 really is, at least in automobile use.  My research dug up three manufacturers of V4 engines for automobiles, and they’re all interesting.

Lancia was the first to debut a V4 in a production car, with the Lambda in 1922.  It was an aluminum-block engine (very rare for the time) with pushrod actuation of the valvetrain.  Displacement varied between 2.1 and 2.6L, with power outputs ranging from 49bhp to 69bhp, which were impressive outputs for the displacement at the time.  It was updated over the years and adapted to many different Lancias, including the Artena, Augusta, Aprilia, Ardea, and Appia.  (What’s with Lancia and these A-names?)  Power and sized ranged from a tiny 903cc and 28.8bhp up to the 55bhp 2.0L Artena.

The final application of the Lancia V4 was used in the gorgeous Fulvia, starting in 1963.  The V4 was drastically redesigned for the Fulvia, with the block angle dropping from 20° in pre-war Lancias to about 12.5°.  This allowed the use of a shared cylinder head (think Volkswagen VR6, then wonder where they got the idea) with two banks of cylinders.  Even cooler, it was a dual overhead cam V engine with only two camshafts – one operating the exhaust valves, one the intake.

LanciaV4-1

The Fulvia’s V4 was available in a dizzying array of states of tune and displacement, ranging from a 1.1L 58bhp version – with low 7.8:1 compression ratio – up to the screaming 1.6L HF-tuned Series II motor, which cranked out 132bhp@6600rpm with an 11.3:1 compression ratio.  The larger 1.6L V4 had it’s block angle dropped down to 11.2° for better balancing.  Here are two good underhood shots of a series 1 Fulvia showing just how strange looking this engine really was.

Lancia Fulvia (S1) V4

I guess changing the spark plugs on this engine wouldn’t be all that difficult, would it?

LanciaV4-3

Sadly, the Lancia V4 died with the Fulvia in 1976, replaced with a more conventional (and much cheaper to produce) inline-four cylinder engine.  The influence of Fiat, which purchased Lancia in 1969, can be seen in the mass-market dumbing down of Lancia with the death of the V4.  But Lancia wasn’t the only company with the idea that a V4 might be a good thing.  Ford dabbled with the V4 as well, and the story of the Euro Ford V4 is an interesting one too.

Ford of Europe actually had two different versions of the V4, one designed and produced by Ford of Germany (called the Taunus V4, it later evolved into the 6-cylinder Cologne series of motors) and one by Ford of England, the Essex V4 – which was named after the plant it was made in, respectively.

Both V4′s featured a counter-rotating balance shaft to neutralize harmonic vibrations inherent in a four-cylinder, an exacerbated by the V formation.  Since one cylinder in a typical crankshaft I/C engine fires every 180°, this means there is no firing overlap with a four cylinder to cancel out the vibrations caused by the starting and stopping of the pistons.  Engines with 5 cylinders and up have overlap and are naturally smoother, although as I’ll discuss soon, the five-cylinder has it’s own balance problems.  Even with the balance shaft, the V4′s were pretty rough little engines, and thanks to their 60° cylinder bank, not as high-revving as the single-head Lancia V4.

The German (Taunus) V4 came in varying displacements, including a 1.2, 1.3, 1.5 and later an enlarged and redesigned 1.7L unit.  The 1.2L unit made 40bhp; the 1.7L cranked out 65.  The Essex V4 was larger, at 1.7L or 2.0L, but didn’t really produce much more power than the German unit.

Saab 96 V4

What’s odd about the Ford V4 was that they licensed it out to Saab.  During the mid-sixties, Saab was looking to replace their three-cylinder two-stroke motors which were losing favor with the mass motoring public – I mean who wants to add in a certain amount of oil at every stop for gas? – and they had no chance of meeting upcoming emissions regulations.  They chose the Ford V4 because it fit in the tiny engine bay of the 95 and 96, although they actually considered licensing the Lancia V4 as well.

The Ford V4-powered Saabs were a big hit with Saab nuts.  While they offered only slight more power than the old 841cc two-stroke (55bhp vs. 40, or 57 in the GT/Monte Carlo with the sweet triple carb setup), the V4 had much more low-end torque, and was simpler and more reliable.  Being a Saab, they had all sorts of weird characteristics – like the siamesed exhaust ports and gear-driven cams.

The V4 could be found under the hood of the Saab Sonnett II V4 and Sonnett III as well, as seen in competition-spec in this picture:

SonnettV4

It saw duty under the hood of German Fords like the Taunus and Capri, and later in enlarged 1.7L with the Granada, Consul, and Transit.  Oh, and the Matra 530. Of course.

The Essex engine was much less interesting, and was much more short-lived.  It’s important to notice that both Ford of Germany and England adapted the engines to V6 layouts, as people weren’t really fond of the naturally rough characteristics of the V4.  No one really bothered to tune the motor besides Saab, who used it to power the 96 to many rally successes.  Works-spec 96′s had bored-out 1933cc V4′s that made a healthy 150bhp; turbocharged ones pushed north of 200bhp.  Saab held onto the V4 the longest, with the last 96 V4 rolling off the line for European consumption in 1980.  It was replaced by the 900, which used a Triumph-derived inline four that was canted 45° to the right for hood clearance..

The Ford V4′s still see use today, mostly in industrial equipment – like pumps and power generators.  In the ford lineup, it was replaced by the overhead-cam “Pinto” inline four, which is still being produced in some forms today.

The final manufacturer of V4 powered automobiles is, I’ll admit, quite a bit weirder.  ZAZ (Zaporizhia) was Ukraine’s main automotive manufacturer during the Soviet era, starting in 1960.  Their most well known product is called the Zaporozhets, which is the communist-era equivalent of the VW Beetle.  Putin seems to like his, so you know it’s gotta be pretty awesome.

Vladimir Putin gazing longingly at his Zaporozhets.  Right.

The Zaporozhets were assembled in the ZAZ factory, but the engines were designed, built, and shipped over for installation by MeMZ (Melitopol Engine Plant).  They were similar in design to the VW flat-four, but had the cylinder banks at a 90° angle for ease of servicing – you can do more without dropping the engine out of the car, obviously.

Zaporozhets MeMZ V4

All the MeMZ engines for the ZAZ cars were pushrod design (cam in block, overhead valves) with iron blocks, and seperate pressed-in steel liners.  Much like the VW, they used a large fan driven off the crank pulley to cool the engine, as well as some adorable “ears” on the rear of the car to direct air into the engine bay.

Early ZAZ motors were either 746 or 887cc, with either 23 or 27 horsepower.  When the second-generation ZAZ’s debuted (looking like an NSU Prinz rather than a Fiat 600) it had a larger 1.2L MeMZ V4, still air cooled, but producing 42bhp.  How much does this look like a Corvair?

ZAZ1

So the V4 wasn’t really all that popular in automotive use, but that wasn’t the case in other fields.  Here’s a (partial) list of motorcycles that use V4 powerplants:  Ducati Desmosedici, Yamaha V-Max, Honda RC212, Honda VF/VFR, Aprilia RSV4… you get the point.  The compact and “square” dimensions of a V4 make a lot more sense when mounted in a motorcycle chassis where space is obviously at a premium.  The Yamaha VMax has been in production since 1985, virtually unchanged from the basic formula (cruiser chassis, muscular tire-burning V4, not that complicated) until a complete redesign last year.

Yamaha V-Max engine (2009)

The new V4 engine, pictured above, is an absolute monster.  It displaces 1,679cc and is a dual-overhead-cam 4 valve design.  Power output is 197bhp@9,000rpm and 123lb-ft@6,500rpm…  which would be very good numbers for a car, much less a two-wheeled contraption.  The V4 is dead, long live the V4!

Share Share on Facebook

 

Share Share on Twitter Share Share ▼
  • http://dr1665.com Brian DR1665

    Very interesting article, James. I was familiar with the V4 in the Saab, but did not know it came from Ford. Likewise, the other models mentioned were new to me as well. I can recall riding in an old Ford Europe Granada, but had no clue at the time how special the engine under the hood might have been.

    Looking forward to 5-cylinders…

  • Pete Shuttleworth

    Brilliant article! I have a 1977 Ford Transit with a 2 Litre Essex V4 and rare-ish auto box. Its done 93thousand + miles and 25000 of them have been on unleaded petrol with no additives or engine mods. Having had some experience of VWs, classic scooters and old minis this really surprised me. However all the folk I’ve spoke to online reckon the old V4 will run a normal life on unleaded without new/machined heads, different valves or any of the aftermarket gizmos (usually with potassium) that classic vehicle owners use. I was wondering if this attribute was unique to the UK FordV4? does anyone know? does anyone but me care? I also drive a Volvo 5cyl (T5) which is exceptionally smooth, and this has led to my wife calling the Transit “Boneshaker”!

  • Toshi

    Great article, thumbs up, a kitcar with that yamaha v-max engine would be brilliant!

  • Pingback: Vw Golf R20 details « Mototreats's Blog

  • mckillio

    Would a 90 degree V4 be smoother than a Inline 4?

    • http://www.saabsnaab.com James

      really wouldn’t, even with counter-rotating balance shafts. THe main reason I4′s become predominant was packaging, but they’re also a lot easier to balance out and run smooth

  • Pingback: Feeling like a moron - Page 2 - Volvo Forums - Volvo Enthusiasts Forum

  • Dean McComas

    Well I like the article but you missed the the thiokol Imp was made by thiokol Chenical co. they are snow grooming machines and rescue vehicals also they were used in some machinery generators and such well I would like to find out more on how to identify them

  • Bear

    So the benefit of a V4 is compactness but the drawback is vibration.
    For some reason it still seems cool.

  • Pablo

    Tengo un Ford taunus 12m con motor 4v 1500cc. La verdad es que es un motor exelente. Me gusta conservarlo casi con todas sus piezas originales aunque esto me trae problemas porque ya cuesta encontrar repuestos. Incluso conservo la dinamo 12voltios funcionando. Cuando afinaba el motor me asombraba lo económico que era. Es un auto muy confiable aunque algo duro para manejar.

  • Acemolecatcher

    In the mid-1950s, BMC investigated the V4 layout, and built some experimental engines with narrow-angle vee and single cylinder head with pushrod OHV. I think the capacity ranged from 1100 to 1500cc. They were road-tested out of Longbridge in Austin A40 Cambridge saloons. Nothing ever came of it, but the last engine wasn’t scrapped until the late 1970s.
    In the early 1980s, British Leyland were approached by VW regarding their narrow-angle vee engines, which at that stage were at an early stage of development. I don’t know if they were looking for a joint-venture partner in the project, or whether they were simply hoping to sell the engines to BL, but nothing came of it, and shortly afterwards BL signed the co-operation agreement with Honda. But before the VW engineers left, they were shown the BMC V4 drawings, and they were absolutely gobsmacked!

    • Ron Boswell

      AUSTIN R@D BUILT 2LITRE V4 ENGINES AND ROAD TESTED THEM IN A55 AND A60 CAMBRIDGE SALOONS. I DROVE AN A60 WITH ONE OF THESE FITTED QUITE A FEW LAPS OF “C” ROUTE AROUND THE COTSWOLDS.
      “HAPPY DAYS”

  • darth elvis

    You’ve not mentioned the relationship of the ford v8s that the v4 and v6 are based upon.

  • Moe Badderman

    # “Some cars used to use leather”
    Some people are used to using “use to use” usage, but others use “use” instead. Get used to using it, Mackintosh.

  • mckillio

    Would a 90 degree V4 not be better balanced than an inline 4?

    • Old Mechanic

      An inline or horizontally opposed 4 cylinder is the first engine that is perfectly balanced – the inside two pistons move together and the outside two move together 180 degrees out of phase. This provides perfect mechanical balance (assuming all moving parts have been ‘blue printed’) and firing pulses are even at every 180 degrees. The next perfectly balanced engine has 12 cylinders.

      • Keith

        False, both an inline 4 and flat four do not have natural balance, the firing frequency does not overlap, and the flat 6, inline 6 are the best perfectly balanced configurations before a 12 cylinder

  • Race Clag

    Maybe time to rethink this idea. The mighty Stuttgart factory has lined them up in a racing application, turbocharged and I would assume this will be used in road applications in the near future. LONG LIVE THE V4!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

TRENDING

ehveug
Ballsy Helicopter Pilots Make Incredible Rally Shots Like This Possible

This rally car emerges from the trees with a helicopter riding behind him just a few feet off the ground

Screenshot 2014-04-14 at 15
Watch This Insane Diesel Drag Truck Get It Horribly Wrong

This Dodge truck gets it badly wrong at about 100mph, crashing through the barriers and onto the grass verge

Screenshot 2014-04-16 at 18
The Only Thing Protecting These Pedestrians From Certain Death By Lorry Was Lady Luck

Casually waiting at an intersection, these pedestrians suddenly found themselves in the path of an out-of-control lorry

Picture 1
It’s Engine Grenading Honda Owners Like This That Kill Manual Cars

“I blew my tranny” is a phrase that no man should have to say, but in the case of a missed gear like this, you know what’s coming…

Picture 10
The Merc SL-Based ‘Filandi Ever S’ Makes The Pontiac Aztec Look Sexy

The hideous Filandi Ever S was created by an Italian guy with zero style and more money than sense

Dacia Sandero
Bargain Hatchback Face-Off: New Sandero Vs Used Panda 100HP

We drive Dacia’s budget Sandero to see if it compares with similarly-priced hatchbacks on the used car market

1390726044_1
Use This Clever Mod To Hoon A 2014 McLaren F1 Car In GTA 4

Ever wanted to drive a Formula 1 car in GTA? Well, now you can thanks to this mod created by EzayGaming

article-2307592-01E7519A000004B0-225_634x458
10 Things You Didn’t Know About The Chinese Grand Prix

The fourth round of the 2014 Formula 1 season takes place this weekend at the Shanghai International Circuit in China